I wasn't paying attention to the tags when I clicked on the book, but yeah, sis con / bro con I find offputting (the girl that works at the school paper seems totally sensible with her criticism, but I guess we're supposed to hate her attitude?). I thought Kuroha was going to be a foil to that trope, but now she's falling into the cliche (but being a Tsundere about it). Maybe they won't go full sis con, and it's more admiration than out and out lust or anything, nothing she would act on.
Also, much like "When Supernatural Battles Become Commonplace", instead of the author really pushing to attack the less fortunate attitudes of Otaku culture (Chuuni ramblings in WSBBC, sis con tropes here), now they're trying to spread Moe and siscon narratives. I thought this'd be more of a subversion / critique of tropes than a celebration of them or movement toward acceptance of the narratives, but we'll see where they go from here. It'd be much more interesting if the brother + Yuzu were unwittingly opposed to Kuroha's literature loves, and Kuroha schemed to change the future.
Also, does Kuroha not see that this is the start of the Orthodox movement? I guess love is blind. :sunglasses:
Edit: One thing I will give Gin in his argument, there are a lot of great anime stories that are scoffed at by others and buried because of tropes and attitudes they have built up about their worth. I'm not saying all the stuff is a work of art, but I think stuff like Attack on Titan is on par with The Walking Dead, and even some of anime's faults get excused in other works (speaking of siscon, how about Game of Thrones? Arrested Development?). Rant over. :zipper_mouth: